Posted by Mark On July - 11 - 2011 12 Comments

I’ll apologize for this in advance.  There is virtually no place in the sports world you can go right now without seeing David Price on his knees trying to reel in that long flyball of Jeter’s bat.  I suspect we are going to see that highlight again a few times.

Before it happened, I had made a conscious decision to ensure that this would be a Jeter-free zone.  I mean, there had to be some harbor that could protect us from the storms of Jeter stories that we all knew would be everywhere.

But, after it happened, I realized that I wouldn’t be able to resist.  Not for the lazy reasons.  But, because there is an angle to this event that no one is writing.  I simply don’t understand why so many people hate Derek Jeter.

I googled "Jeter" and "Tebow" and Google broke. My apologies to everyone in Palo Alto that was on call today. I should have thought that one through.

(Caveat, we are only talking about sports hate, not REAL hate.  If you REALLY hate Derek Jeter — or anyone you don’t know — please take your business elsewhere.  This space is reserved for the sane.)

Look, I am just as sick of the Jeter coverage as everyone else.  But, I understand it.  I mean, 3,000 hits is a BIG deal.  Huge deal.  When I was working for the Devil Rays in 1999, I remember how much work went into preparing for Boggs 3,000th and, the lasting impression I took away was, this is hard to do and should be celebrated.  In an era when a lot of hallowed records were sullied, 3,000 stands clean (mostly…I am looking at you Raffy).    So, regardless of the hitter, this was going to get some juice.  As it should.

But, even if you think it is overblown, is that a reason to dislike Jeter?  In the end, it seems that the Jeter-hate comes from two or three sources: 1) He has been a good player on good teams that have beaten your favorite team; 2) The media covers him like he’s Elvis; 3) He is a Yankee.

Reasons 1 and 3 are certainly grounds to root against Jeter.  I hope he never gets another hit.  I was hoping he wouldn’t get any hits against us.  But, that isn’t because I hate him.  I simply don’t want players on teams we are chasing to perform well because I’d like for us to catch them.  In fact, I root against Jeter just like I root against Ramiro Pena, no more and no less.

Reason 2, however, is the most interesting.  Jeter obviously has no control over the amount of media coverage he receives.  That kind of comes with the territory when you are the Yankee captain.  Moreover, he doesn’t do anything to court the media, like his infield mate.

In the end, I think all the Jeter-hate is reminiscent of the Tebow-hate (back when Tim Tebow was a relevant athlete…you know…before the NFL).  There isn’t any real reason to dislike him.  He doesn’t seek attention, taunt opponents, or do any of the other things primadonna athlete-celebrities doe.  Compare him to A-Rod and tell me where you come out.  No, I think the people that “hate” Jeter really just are sick of him.  Too much Jeter (just like too much Tebow) innately makes you turn away when more is offered.

But, that isn’t really a reason to sports-hate Jeter.  (A hard lesson the Mrs. had to teach me about Tebow).  In the end, the guy has been good for baseball.  And I am glad to have seen him play.  But I hope he takes the collar once play resumes after the break.

Categories: Featured, Slider

12 Responses

  1. Mike McK says:

    I personally think that he gets a lot of “special” attention because he is a yankee and not for his particular talent. I truly believe he is a good sport and good athlete. He has charisma and plays for Yankees. That combination catapults you into celebrity status that he would have never gotten if he had played for the Arizona Diamondbacks.

    • Mark says:

      That’s definitely true. But he IS particularly talented. No amount of added fame can get you to 3,000 hits. Right?

      • Mike McK says:

        I definitely agree with your statement. To have the longevity and numbers he has, it truly a talent. I think this is where people’s hatred or should I say, jealousy comes in. Most people for cities outside of New York have their favorite all star. Craig Biggio and Paul Molitor who are also in the 3000 club never nearly got the recognition that Jeter gets, just for being Jeter. The fact of the matter is, that New York is a “hollywood” team. Big city, big money and big personality always make the headlines.

    • J says:

      I feel alot of sports-hate comes from Jeter always being selected as the AL all-star SS starter many years there have been other SS with better AVG, fielding %, and RBI’s. This year Jeter was 10th or 14th in all of those catorgories.

      • Mark says:

        Perhaps, but that is another one of those things outside his control. In fact, he declined to participate this year and seemed to have taken more hate than had he participated.

  2. Merrill says:

    The umpires make me hate him. He must have the most liberal PA’s of any ball player in the world. Did Jeter swing on a close one? If not, it must have been a ball…it looks almost assumed that Jeter would only NOT swing on a ball. The ball came within inches of Jeter (or hit his damn bat)? Well that’s a free base for you, sir!

    I’d love to see him treated like every other player and see how his games ended up lining up on the stats sheet.

    • Mark says:

      That reminds me of a great story about Ty Cobb that I heard once. Cobb took a close pitch and the umpire called it a ball. The catcher told the umpire it was a strike and the umpire responded “Son, if that was a strike, I am certain Mr. Cobb would have swung at it.”

  3. Mike McK says:

    I don’t think people hate Tebow as much as most people think. I think Tebow gets a bad rap because of “Gator Fan”. I found myself not liking Tebow for a while until I realized I had no reason not to like him other than I was tired of Gator Fan talking about him non stop. I think Tebow regardless if he ever achieves anything in his NFL career is one of the most inspirational and truly talented athletes to ever play the game. Also, in today’s society, people want to see trainwrecks. Tebow is far from that. Most people want a reason to not like someone and the fact that he is a “good guy”, some people have a problem with that.

  4. Leanne says:

    Up until DJ3K became the non-stop hit on the GrandDaddy of cable sports (cable itself for that matter), the vast majority of non Yankees fans I’ve known called Jeter the only Yankee they really liked. The saturation of all-Jeter all the time definitely got old. This shortly following the circus act that was the Jeter signing Favre-esque episode, following the “Jeter? Starting All-Star? Is that how bad AL SS’s are these days?” unending chatter, etc.

    It was the sports media version of waiting for the continually rising river to finally overwhelm the levees. And for many, our levees just couldn’t hold any more. Despite being a Rays fan, I do think that it was good that it was off of David Price and not some guy whose only footnote in Baseball would be the asterisk next to Jeter3000. Perhaps with the Home Run, even some Yankee fans will get their fill, satisfied bellies and start just focusing on the rest of the season and the long pennant race.

    • Mark says:

      Congratulations Leanne! You just made the 1,000th comment at The Ray Area! For that, there is no prize, but you get the respect of your peers and the admiration of the many lurkers. Great work. The countdown to TRA3K is on!

      • Leanne says:

        Why Thank You Mark. Like most chicks who like sports, I’m kinda used to the admiration of lurkers. :)

        But respect…WOW! And you said there’s no prize. :)

Leave a Reply

Featured Posts

Yankees Rays Baseball 1

The Good and The Bad at The En

Lets start with congratulations to David Price.  In fact, lets add congratulations to the Rays' ...

Parks

Ballpark Tax

The Times has a blurb this morning in the business section about a news Rays ...

22tigers-pic-articleLarge

The Fall[ish] Classic

At long last, it is World Series time. There is plenty of winter ahead.  Plenty of ...

Longo Walk Off September 2011

Last Days

Last night was one final knife.  One more great pitching performance squandered. Lets not talk about.  ...

Evan+Longoria+Cincinnati+Reds+v+Tampa+Bay+0jdLxCSLYZ3l

Don't Worry...

...I'm still alive. I just am being cautious because: September 18, 2012: Loyalty vs. Honesy, Red Sox ...

Sponsors